by
Oregano
@ 2008-01-12 - 11:55:09
A few days ago Ranfuchs made a posting "The problem with chicken" raising concerns about how egg-laying chickens were treated and the fact the eggs fron intensively reared birds went into many foods. I must admit that, while I was always aware that battery hens were reared in cruel conditions and that "value" chicken meat often looks an odd colour, I do not know a lot about the subject.
I rarely watch TV but when I got back from Finland my wife said that I would have be interested in Hugh Fearnley-Whittingstall's Chicken Run series. I did not see the series of 3 programmes, but basically it records how our supermarkets have driven down the price of chicken so much that farmers have little choice but to offer cheap intensively-reared chicken otherwise it will be purchased abroad. He set up two similar chicken sheds: the first raised 2,500 chickens in intensive conditions and the other 1,500 chickens in more humane conditions. There was an inevitable contrast in both the way in which the chickens grew and the quality of the meat after slaughtering. He then went on to try to convince Axminster, Devon to be the first 'free range town' in Britain. However today's Independent in an article entitled Crying Fowl suggests that his way of working and filming with a local chicken farm was less than fair.
Last night Jamie Oliver presented a complementary programme called "Fowl Dinners" which challenged a studio audience about the chicken they ate. A few farms were visited (both egg and meat) and some industry figures were interviewed. While the intensive rearing conditions shown - with a high mortality rate - were shocking, what shocked me most is that intensively reared chickens are sold for 3p per bird at the farm gate! I have previously heard of how lamb prices were incredibly low but this blew me away. So for a £2.50 supermarket bird the farmer just gets 1.2% of the sale price - that is obscene!There are obviously transport, slaughtering, packing and retailing costs but I suspect that the supermarket takes the lion's share of that.
A few years ago I saw a programme showing that a huge number of chicken breasts were imported from Thailand via the Netherlands. In the Netherlands they were injected with protein and water (to max up the weight) then imported here. The commencial threat to British farmers if their goods are not cheap enough that they will lose out to imports is real enough.
I think that our supermarkets and their desire to make huge profits on cheap food are the main driver behind the intensive farming methods used for meat and eggs. However another contributor has been the big change in our cooking habits. Chicken consumption has gone up massively in my lifetime. In my childhood a whole chicken was a typical Sunday lunch choice - like a joint of prime beef or a leg of lamb - a luxury meal that was an infrequent treat. Today chicken consumption is far greater driven by a dramatic reduction in costs in real terms plus a move from red to white meat for health reasons.
From what I recall of the 1970s you could buy whole chickens fresh or frozen and there was little alternative. A typical British family then would probably roast the chicken whole and stuff it. When the chicken was carved you were asked if you preferred the light (breast) or dark (meat) and everybody had their preferences. From what I recall the dark meat was generally regarded as superior. The carcase might then be put into a pressure cooker to make a soup or stock rather than being dumped in the bin.
When I got to university I realised that my Asian fellow-students approached the chicken differently. They would take a whole chicken, chop it up with a meat cleaver into bite size pieces and either put the pieces in a stir fry (Chinese) or in a curry (Indian). The pieces of meat would usually be served on the bone apart from the breast. Since I got to like cooking Chinese and Indian things I too purchased a meat cleaver from the Chinese supermarket.
Around 1980, I became aware of supermarkets selling chicken breasts. I was surprised when a friend's wife served a meal that was just chicken breasts. To be fair, drumsticks and chicken wings were also offered in the supermarkets but this was a big change from whole chickens. However, a huge number of people now only eat chicken breast. This of course leads to problems - if people eat mainly chicken breasts what happens to the rest? Well of course there is machine recovered meat that goes into junk food and horrifyingly some non-breast meat has been sold at a dumping price in West Africa putting local farmers out of business (sorry I cannot find the reference).
Not only do we need to worry about chicken welfare, but we should relearn how to use whole chickens. A well-reared whole chicken ought to supply a family with a few meals without costing a fortune. It is perhaps just at the cost of a little more time - time is precious but many of us waste enough of it in front of a TV or game console!
Hugh's Chicken Run will be repeated (don't know which of the 3 programmes) on Channel 4 tonight at 17:35